What exactly is sugar? Where does it come from? How much should I eat each day? What are the benefits of limiting sugars?
Some of you may have seen or tried to follow one of today’s popular “belly-fat busting” low sugar diets. One of the more popular ones has been making its way into my inbox and awareness lately. Now, I’m not one to promote healthy eating for the sake of vanity, but since I put on a couple 3 pounds during the holiday and I’m going on an extended vaction soon, I want to have my bathing suit body ready. I was wondering how I could drop an inch off the waistline without too much trouble or deprivation and though I’d give it a go. I usually like to experiment with different eating patterns before I recommend them to clients; I’m my own guinea pig!
First, lets talk about what sugar is. For all practical purposes, sugar is a sweet, simple carbohydrate. The common “monosaccharides” are single molecule sugars such as fructose, glucose, and galactose. The primary “disaccharides” are double molecules of those . For example, sucrose (table sugar) is glucose + fructose and lactose (milk sugar) is glucose + galactose
Sugar may be added to food as cane sugar, brown sugar, beet sugar, glucose (dextrose), agave, maple syrup, or other sweeteners derived from natural sources. Sugar also occurs naturally in food such as lactose in milk products or fructose in fruit.
Sugars are considered a class of carbohydrates.Other carbs, such as starches and fiber, are made up of longer, more complex chains of the monosaccharides. Most of these longer chains (excluding the non-digestible fibers) ultimately become glucose in the bloodstream, just like their simple sugar cousins. Usually, starches break down more slowly and cause less extreme elevations and resultant dips in blood sugar, especially if they are “complex, whole foods” starches such as whole grains or starchy vegetables and if they are part of a balanced meal or snack.
1 teaspoon of sugar is 4 grams. Current recommendations are for no more than 6-8 teaspoons of added sugars each day, that is 16-32 grams per day of sweeteners. Naturally, I think it would be easier if they put that recommendation in grams since sugars are listed in grams on the nutrition facts panel of packaged foods. However, The sugar on a food label is listed in grams and does not differentiate between natural sugars and added sugars and currently there are no guidelines around sugars that occur naturally in foods. Also, there is no way to determine, on a carton of chocolate milk for example, how many of those grams are added and how many are naturally occuring sugars.
One practical concern with excess sugar consumption is that it is rapidly absorbed, quickly elevates blood sugar and leads to further sugar and carbohydrate cravings. Sugar is a viscous cycle, the more you eat the more you want. Elevated blood sugar stimulates the release of insulin; insulin loves to store sugar; guess how it is stored? Thats right- as fat! As well, insulin prefers to store that fat in the waist area, nestled right in there with our vital organs. This is called “visceral fat” and is the most metabolically active and dangerous type of fat as it interferes with our metabolism, hormone balance, and organ function (fatty liver, anyone?)
Sugar is not necessary for life; we can get plenty of carbohydrate from a vegetable-heavy diet, eating some complex starches, and fruits. Biochemically, we can make energy from proteins or fat, we don’t necessarily even need carbohydrates to survive! So what is the point of all this sugar? Well, its delicious for one and it gives us pleasure, both reasons why we crave sweet foods. From an evolutionary perspective, if something gives us pleasure, we seek it out. We were designed to seek out food to maintain and propogate life; its a fairly simple equation. However, we exist now in a carb-obsessed, sugar-saturated culture where we want and expect everything to be super sweet. The average adult eats 22 teaspoons (88 grams) of added sugar daily with teenagers reaching an astounding and disturbing average of 34 teaspoons a day (136 grams!). Picture what 34 teaspoons of sugar looks like, thats almost one full cup! 22 teaspoons is about 1/2 cup. One regular soda has 8 tsp of added sugar. That is a whole day’s recommended limit, and for what?
The popular belly fat busting plan I am following limits all sugars regardless of if they are naturally occuring or added. The goal of this plan is to not exceed 16 grams of sugar (from all sources, added and naturally-occuring) nor 6 carbohyrate choices. I’m about a week into this plan as I type, and wow(!!!) it is hard! I pretty much follow the carb thing already and I rarely exceed 6-8 carb choices each day; the sugar thing, however, is more complicated. An apple or a small yogurt meets and exceeds the sugar limit for the day! So far I have not been able to keep my total sugars at 16 grams or less and therefore, have not seen great results, even with drastically limiting sugars compared to what I was eating before. I would often eat 2-3 servings of fruit daily, indulged in dark chocolate regularly and ocassionally had treats at home like cookies or hot chocolate. I’ll keep trying and keep you posted! Only 3 weeks until we fly out, so I’d better get it in line and see how it shakes out. I won’t post every single day, as that would be tiresome, but when I do hit the magic numbers, I’ll be sure to post the day so you can get an idea what it looks like. Wish me luck!
In this post, “CHO” means carbohydrate and it represents a unit of “exchanges” or “choices”. Each exchange/choice equals 15 grams of carb; that is about 1 slice of bread, 1/2 cup pasta potatoes or squash, 1/3 cup beans or rice, etc etc. You can easily find more information online regarding carbohydrate exchanges.
What I’m using to determine sugar content is the USDA nutrient database. Any program that counts calories, grams of this, or milligrams of that uses data that originates here.
The meat listed in this diary is all grass-fed beef and pork from our local farmer, sustainably sourced seafood, or organic chicken.
I’ve been using xylitol-sweetened products as it is not a traditional sugar, but a sugar alcohol that supplies less energy (calories) than sugar and for the most part is not absorbed in the same way and does not increase our fat-storing hormones. Xylitol is the main sugar in Designs for Health Paleobars which you will see I eat a couple of times a week.
Day 1
I don’t usually eat packaged cereals as they tend to be very high sugar, but I didn’t prepare my whole grain cereal the night before (soaked for improved digestibility and quicker cooking) so I grabbed one serving of a hempseed granola that was in the cupboard.
Breakfast
- 3/4cup Nature’s Path granola: 10g sugar, 1.5 CHO
- 1/2 cup blueberries: 9g sugar–> over my limit already!! 0.5 CHO
- 3/4 cup homemade pecan milk: 2g sugar
I add a tiny bit of apple juice to my homemade pecan milk and figure one serving as about 2g sugar.
Here, I knew I was already over my limit, but went for it anyway. I asked the barista if I could read the package of the soymilk; it listed 1 cup as having 6 grams of sugar.
- Soy cappuccino: 6g sugar, 0.5 CHO
Mid-morning Snack
- PaleoBar, berry flavor: 2g sugar
Total so far= 29 grams and I haven’t even hit lunch!
Lunch
- 1 cup quinoa: 2 CHO
- ~4 oz chicken
- cilantro, green onion, olive oil, and lemon dressing
- 1 raw carrot
- 1 oz dark chocolate: 3g
- coconut chia seed pudding: ?! When you are buying food from a deli or eating in a restaurant, it is very hard to estimate the sugars. At the deli counter they told me that they add about 1 cup of maple syrup for about 18 servings of pudding. 1 cup is 16 Tablespoons, so that is roughly 0.88 tablespoons per serving. The USDA database lists 0.88 Tbsp of maple syrup as having 11g sugar.
Since I exceeded my sugar goal, I didn’t eat any more sugar-foods (fruit included) and therefore didn’t record dinner. Dinner was probably pretty low carb, something like vegetables and meat or fish.
wow- this is hard!
Total: 43 grams sugar, 5-6 servings of CHO
Day 2
Breakfast
- Coffee with unsweetened coconut creamer
- 2 slices red rice, gluten free bread: 4g sugar, 2 CHO
- 1/2 banana: 8g sugar, 1 CHO
- 2 Tbsp almond butter
- 1 Tbsp raw, organic honey: 17g sugar (!!!), 1 CHO
Oops, breakfast put me 2 times over the limit; I could have done without either the honey or the banana.
Total so far: 29g sugar!
Mid-morning Snack
- Handul of raw nuts (my own soaked and lightly roasted)
- green tea
- 1 cup pomegranate seeds: 24g sugar- wow! I had no idea; I just learned this by looking it up on the USDA database I mentioned earlier; 1.5g CHO
- 1.5 cup split pea soup with potato, ham hock, collard greens: 2-3 CHO
- MSM powder, raspberry flavor, sweetened with xylitol
Afternoon Tea
- green tea
- 3 Tim Tams- I didn’t even bother to read the label for sugar on these, I knew it was pointless! I went off any dietary limits I have set for myself; they’re full of gluten and full of sugar! yummy. We had these wonderful dark chocolate cookies sent all the way from Australia by some dear family members. I enjoyed them thoroughly without guilt or self-recrimination, and now I know how many grams of sugar: 8 grams each, for a grand total of 24grams sugar and 2 CHO
- Nutrition cocktail: Paleofiber, greens powder, with CoQ10
- 4 chicken wings dipped in:
- Bleu cheese crumbles mixed with omega-3 mayonnaise, Greek yogurt, water
- 1 celery stalk
- 2 cups salad greens with herb vinegar and olive oil
- 1 cup pistachios (measured in shells)
There is some sugar in yogurt and cheese, I just compared it to a regular, commercial blue cheese dressing. A 1/4 cup has 2 grams sugar.
Total: 55 grams sugar and 9.5 CHO choices! The worst yet.
Day 3
Breakfast
- green tea
- 1 cup buckwheat cereal with egg, 2 CHO
I decided to have egg instead of fruit in my hot cereal to work on decreasing my sugar after falling of the wagon yesterday (thanks Australia!). It made for a substantial and savory breakfast.
- 8oz coffee with xylitol hazelnut flavor and 1 Tbsp cream (organic)
Mid-morning Snacking
- Paleobar: 2g sugar
- Greek yogurt with chia and milk thistle seeds: 19g sugar, 1 CHO
I decide to bring a yogurt as my treat, knowing that that would be it for sugars for the day. Lets see how the rest of the day went…
Lunch
- Baked halibut, red chard with mushroom, onion, and blue cheese: no sugar no carb
Dinner
- 1 cup kale salad, BBQ chips, Mary’s Gone gluten-free crackers: 2 CHO, 3g sugar
It is really hard to try to pick out something on the go when you’re trying to live the low sugar lifestyle. I grabbed some potato chips as they usually have NO grams of sugar, of course the BBQ flavor added a couple of grams. Overall today was better then yesterday!
Total: 21g sugar, 5 CHO
Day 3
Breakfast
- Biogenesis Ultra Lean chocolate shake: no sugar, no carbs
- Chia, flax, milk thistle seeds
- Pecan milk: 2g sugar
Mid-morning Snack
- Handful of raw nuts
- 1 apple: 18g, 1 CHO
Lunch
- 1.5-2 cups soup: sprouted garbanzo bean, spaghetti squash, and chicken: 2 CHO
- Salad greens with olive oil and vinegar
In the afternoon, I chewed on
- Xylitol mints
- Handful of raw nuts
Afternoon Tea
- Green tea
- 2 rice cakes: 2CHO
- 1/2 avocado
- 2 slices turkey (contains sugar, but <1g)
- 1/2 oz goat cheese
Dinner
- 1/4 tuna cake; this is egg with onion and tuna cooked like a pancake or Spanish “tortilla”: no carb, no sugar
- greens with feta, raspberry vinegar and olive oil
Total: 20g sugar, 5 CHO. Closest day yet!
Day 4 & 5
The weekend got away from me a little, I wasn’t counting grams of sugar or carbs. I did continue to read labels to limit sugar intake and be aware of carbs. Basically, I was enjoying my usual diet and snacking on some dark chocolate almonds and fresh fruit without getting too worked up about the sugar.
Wanting to satisfy some sweet cravings, I made a xylitol hot chocolate drink I have heard about from the people at “Metabolic Effect”. It is about 1:2 xylitol crystals to pure, organic, unsweetened cocoa powder and unsweetened almond milk. First, you mix the xylitol and cocoa (about 1 Tbsp : 2Tbsp per cup), add a little hot water and mix into a paste. To make the hot chocolate and hot almond milk. You can also just eat it like a paste (imagine its chocolate frosting!) with a tiny spoon. This is supposed to really nip any sugar cravings in the bud and give you some powerful antioxidants as well!
Ready to start counting again on Monday!
Day 6
Breakfast
- green tea
- 1 cup 3 grain hot cereal: 2CHO
- 1/2 cup pecan milk: 2g
- 1/2 cup blueberries: 9g, 1CHO
- 1/2 banana: 8g sugar, 1 CHO
1oAM Snack
- Handful of raw nuts
- orange: 12g sugar, 1 CHO
- another handful of nuts
Lunch
- 1 cup roasted acorn squash with apples, onions, and thyme: ~ 5g sugar, 2 CHO
- 2 oz beef
- green salad with vinegar and olive oil
Tea
- green tea
- 1 rice cake: 1CHO
- 1/4 avocado
- 1 slice ham
- 1 slice goat cheese
Dinner
- 3 oz salmon baked with lemon and garlic
- 1 cup potato/cauliflower mash: 1 CHO
I usually make my mashed potatoes with an equal amount of cauliflower to decrease carbs and increase veggie potential. I use chicken stock and either a little butter and/or Greek yogurt. If I have recently roasted a chicken, I use that super nutritious gel-like substance that is left in the bottom of the pan. It contains some fat but also important nutrients; traditionally, this is something like an aspic or “meat jelly”. I know, sounds gross, but its actually delicious and very handy for replacing traditional fats in cooking.
- salad greens with lemon and olive oil
- 1/4 avocado
- ~1/2 pear and 1/2 banana with 2 Tbsp plain Greek yogurt, drizzled with “miel de palma”. probably about 15-20gram sugar, 1.5CHO
Couldn’t help eating more fruit today. Miel de Palma is a syrup from a palm plant or tree, it is definitely not considered low sugar!
So far, I have not been able to meet the sugar goal; not doing so bad with trying to eat 6 or less CHO choices. The upside is that I’m learning a lot about the sugar content of foods and that hopefully this will be useful for you as well.
I will be sure to blog when I have reached my goal, even if its just for one day!